Unlisted Shares Valuation: Are Unlisted Share Prices Fair?

Are Unlisted Shares Being Correctly Valued? A Reality Check on the Unlisted Market

Key Takeaways

●     Rapid price increases in unlisted shares do not always reflect business fundamentals.

●     Limited transparency makes unlisted shares more sensitive to hype.

●     Pre-IPO valuation often prices in future success far in advance

●     Grey market transactions can distort true value perception.n

●     Investors need valuation discipline, not momentum-driven decision-making

Why Pricing Moves Faster Than Fundamentals in the Unlisted Market

One of the biggest differences between listed and unlisted shares is the pace at which prices can change. In the unlisted market, even a small surge in demand can push prices sharply higher because supply is limited. When combined with rising interest in pre-IPO valuation opportunities, this creates a situation where price momentum often runs ahead of business performance.

Unlike listed stocks, where valuation multiples are constantly tested by market participation, unlisted share price movements can remain unchecked for long periods. This makes valuation drift a real risk, especially when investors rely heavily on recent transactions as reference points rather than underlying financial strength.

Tata Capital: When Brand Strength Commands a Heavy Premium

Tata Capital has emerged as one of the most discussed unlisted companies in recent times. Over a short span, the unlisted share price moved from around ₹500 to nearly ₹1,100. Even after some cooling off, the unlisted stock price continues to trade near ₹1,075.

From a valuation perspective, the concern lies in the multiples being implied. In the NBFC space, price-to-book ratios typically range between 1x and 1.5x. Tata Capital, however, is trading close to 21x book value. Such a premium assumes long-term consistency, strong asset quality, and limited downside risk. While the business has scale, the current unlisted shares valuation leaves very little room for disappointment.

Hexaware Technologies: Pre-IPO Optimism at a Cost

Hexaware Technologies highlights how IPO anticipation can influence pricing in the unlisted market. With the company filing its DRHP, investor interest increased rapidly, pushing the unlisted share price to around ₹1,100.

At this level, the valuation implies a price-to-earnings multiple of roughly 125. When compared to the broader IT sector, where average P/E ratios fall between 25 and 35, the gap becomes hard to ignore. This suggests that pre-IPO valuation expectations are already pricing in significant future growth, increasing downside risk if expectations are not met.

Waaree Energies: Sector Tailwinds Versus Valuation Comfort

The solar industry has strong long-term potential, supported by policy initiatives and rising demand. Waaree Energies has benefited from this narrative, with its unlisted share price trading between ₹2,800 and ₹3,000.

However, valuation metrics paint a cautious picture. A P/E ratio of around 62 and a P/B ratio near 19 indicate that the market has already priced in much of the anticipated growth. In the unlisted market, sector optimism alone may not be enough to justify such stretched valuations without consistent profit expansion.

OYO: Turnaround Expectations Driving Pricing

OYO’s valuation journey reflects how turnaround stories influence unlisted shares' valuation. After raising capital at a significantly reduced valuation, the company expanded operations across international markets. Shares issued at around ₹30 now trade close to ₹60 in the unlisted market.

While this price movement may appear reasonable on the surface, the implied valuation of approximately ₹39,000 crore assumes a smooth transition to sustained profitability. The current unlisted share price reflects optimism around future performance rather than present financial strength.

CIAL: Growth Reflected Fully in the Price

CIAL’s valuation changed notably after a 1:4 rights issue in early 2023, priced at ₹50. Since then, the unlisted stock price climbed from about ₹200 to nearly ₹465.

At these levels, the company trades close to 49 times earnings, with a market valuation exceeding ₹22,000 crore. While operational improvements are visible, the pricing suggests that much of the growth potential is already reflected, leaving limited upside from a valuation standpoint.

Hero Fincorp: Premium Pricing in an NBFC Context

Hero Fincorp’s financial arm is trading near ₹2,200 per share, with a price-to-book multiple of about 4.8. In comparison, the broader NBFC sector typically trades between 1x and 1.5x book value.

Although the company has filed papers to raise additional capital, the current unlisted shares valuation implies a premium of nearly three times the sector average. This places greater importance on execution and asset quality going forward.

HDB Financial Services: When Grey Market Prices Outrun Expectations

HDB Financial Services is currently trading between ₹1,490 and ₹1,545, marking an all-time high in the unlisted market. With a market capitalisation exceeding ₹1.2 lakh crore, expectations are clearly elevated.

However, IPO estimates have suggested lower valuation ranges closer to ₹800. This disconnect highlights how grey market pricing can sometimes move ahead of what public markets may be willing to accept.

What Investors Should Take Away

The unlisted market offers genuine opportunities, but it also magnifies valuation risks when enthusiasm overtakes analysis. Rising unlisted share price trends do not automatically indicate value creation. In many cases, they reflect scarcity, anticipation, and narrative-driven demand.

Unlisted shares valuation works best when investors slow down, compare sector multiples, and question what is already priced in. Whether evaluating pre-IPO valuation or tracking movements in the grey market, disciplined analysis remains the most reliable safeguard.

FAQs

1. Why are unlisted shares seeing sharp price increases recently?

Unlisted shares have seen price increases due to rising investor interest, limited supply, and strong focus on pre-IPO opportunities. In many cases, pricing is influenced by demand in the grey market rather than underlying business fundamentals.

2. How reliable are unlisted shares compared to listed stocks?

Unlisted shares' valuation is generally less transparent than listed stocks because there is no continuous price discovery. Valuations often depend on negotiated transactions, recent deals, and expectations rather than real-time market consensus.

3. Can unlisted share price trends be misleading?

Yes. Unlisted share price movements can sometimes reflect short-term hype or scarcity instead of actual financial performance. This is why valuation discipline is especially important in the unlisted market.

4. Are unlisted companies always overvalued before an IPO?

Not always. Some unlisted companies are fairly valued or even undervalued. However, when pre-IPO excitement builds, valuations can stretch beyond fundamentals, increasing downside risk after listing.

5. Should investors rely on the grey market to assess value?

The grey market can provide pricing signals, but it should not be the sole basis for investment decisions. Investors should combine grey market data with financial analysis, business fundamentals, and long-term outlook.

Disclaimer

This content is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered financial or investment advice. Investments in unlisted shares, unlisted companies, and pre-IPO shares involve risks, including limited liquidity, pricing volatility, and uncertainty around future listings. Unlisted share price and valuation in the grey market may not reflect the company’s intrinsic value or eventual listing price. Readers are advised to conduct their own research and consult qualified financial professionals before making any investment decisions.